Friday, June 22, 2012

Defense Rebuts Insanity Claim in Breivik Trial - ABC News

Mike Nova's starred items


ABC News


Defense Rebuts Insanity Claim in Breivik Trial
ABC News
Defense Rebuts Insanity Claim in Breivik Trial. ... him legally sane, saying he suffers from a dissocial and narcissistic personality disorder, but is not psychotic.
Breivik Smiles As Prosecutors State Insanity VerdictCare2.com (blog)
Anders Breivik and the trouble with defining sanityThe Guardian (blog)

all 1,644 news articles » 

Defense Rebuts Insanity Claim in Breivik Trial


On the last day of his trial, Anders Behring Breivik's defense lawyers on Friday tried to cast the confessed mass killer as a political militant motivated by an extreme right-wing ideology rather than a delusional madman who killed 77 people for the sake of killing.
Since Breivik has admitted to the bomb-and-gun attacks on July 22, the self-styled anti-Muslim militant's mental state has been the key focus of the 10-week trial.
Nevertheless, Breivik's defense lawyer Geir Lippestad requested that the 32-year-old Norwegian be acquitted or given the mildest possible prison term for the country's worst peacetime massacre. The plea for acquittal was made out of principle, without any realistic chance of success: Breivik claims he acted in defense of his nation and that the killings were therefore justified.
In his closing arguments, Lippestad reiterated that Breivik accepts that he set off a bomb outside a government high-rise and then gunned down dozens of teenagers at a Labor Party youth camp in the way that the attacks were described in court.
"That little, safe Norway would be hit by such a terror attack is almost impossible to understand," Lippestad said. And that helps explain why psychiatric experts reached different conclusions about Breivik's mental state, he added.
Lippestad tried to prove to the court that Breivik's claims of being a resistance fighter in a struggle to protect Norway and Europe from being colonized by Muslims are not delusional, but part of a political view shared by other right-wing extremists.
null
AP
Anders Behring Breivik, the confessed gunman... View Full Caption
 

He also refuted assertions by one team of psychiatrists that the driving force behind Breivik's attacks was a psychotic impulse to kill, rather than a political ideology.
"July 22 was an inferno of violence," Lippestad said. "But we must also look at how he carried out the attacks to see whether it was violence in itself or radical politics that was the cause."
"He realized that it is wrong to kill but he chose to kill. That's what terrorists do," Lippestad said. "The ends justify the means. You don't understand this if you don't understand the culture of right-wing extremists."
When Breivik talks about a civil war he's not fantasizing about tanks and soldiers in the forest, but referring to a low-intensity struggle he believes will last for 60 years, Lippestad said.
"None of us know what Europe will look like in 60 years," Lippestad said. "Who would have thought 10 years ago that a right-wing extremist party in Greece would get 10 percent in the election now?"
Two teams of psychiatrists reached opposite conclusions about Breivik's mental health. The first team diagnosed him with "paranoid schizophrenia," a serious mental illness. The second team found him legally sane, saying he suffers from a dissocial and narcissistic personality disorder, but is not psychotic.
Prosecutors on Thursday called for an insanity ruling, saying there was enough doubt about Breivik's mental state to preclude a prison sentence.
The five-judge panel is expected to make a ruling in July or August. If deemed mentally competent, Breivik would likely be given Norway's maximum prison term of 21 years. A sentence can be extended beyond that if a prisoner is considered a menace to society. If declared insane, he would be committed to a mental institution for as long as he's considered sick and dangerous to others. Prosecutors suggested Thursday that could mean he would be held for the rest of his life.
Lippestad's otherwise focused statement ended on a confusing note when he asked the court for the most lenient possible prison sentence for his client. After being corrected by Breivik, Lippestad said the defense asks for an acquittal or a lenient sentence, but primarily wants the court to reject the insanity claim.


Prosecutors want mass killer Breivik ruled insane - Reuters



Prosecutors want mass killer Breivik ruled insane
Reuters
OSLO (Reuters) - Prosecutors asked a Norwegian court on Thursday to declare far- right mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik insane and commit him to a ...



Anders Behring Breivik legally insane, says prosecutor
Herald Sun
SELF-confessed Norwegian mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik is legally insane and should be remanded into "compulsory mental heath care," prosecutor ...


Telegraph.co.uk


Anders Behring Breivik 'should be declared insane'
Telegraph.co.uk
Anders Behring Breivik, the confessed gunman who killed 77 people last year in a bomb and shooting rampage, reacts in court as prosecutors deliver their ...

via Breivik Syndrome - Google Blog Search by Baron Bodissey on 6/21/12
This concerns a very nutty Norwegian professor who sincerely hopes that Anders Behring Breivik will be given the chance to return to society at some stage. Notice also ..... Down's Syndrome Babies, Sarah Palin and the BBC ...

Prosecutors on Thursday asked a court to send confessed mass killer Anders Behring Breivik to a mental institution instead of prison for his massacre of 77 people in a ...

via anders behring breivik - Google Blog Search by Bruce Hall on 6/21/12
Prosecutors in Norway have called for self-confessed mass killer Anders Behring Breivik to be considered insane in their closing argument at his trial. Prosecutor Svein Holden said there were still doubts about his insanity but ...


WRAL.com


Breivik Smiles As Prosecutors State Insanity Verdict
Care2.com (blog)
A Norwegian psychiatrist, Ulrik Fredrik Malt of the University of Oslo, has proposed that Breivik has Asperger's Syndrome and Tourette's Syndrome, and that he ...
Norway prosecutors assert that Breivik insaneWRAL.com
Anders Breivik and the trouble with defining sanityThe Guardian (blog)

all 1,068 news articles »


Mike Nova's starred items


Hollywood Reporter


Media Circus Quiet as Trial of Norwegian Killer Winds Down
Hollywood Reporter
The Oslo court is expected to issue its verdict against mass killer Anders Behring Breivik in July or August.



Anders Behring Breivik trial: Norway killer 'insane,' should get ...
GlobalPost
Prosecutors in the trial of Anders Behring Breivik have asked for him to be considered insane and sent to a psychiatric facility, not prison.



Norway prosecutors assert that Breivik insane
Ct Post
Even though self-styled anti-Muslim militant Anders Behring Breivik insists he is sane and that he carried out the July 22 attacks for political reasons, prosecutors ...


National Post


Anders Behring Breivik grins as Norway prosecutors ask for him to ...
National Post
Prosecutors asked a Norwegian court on Thursday to declare far- right mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik insane and commit him to a mental institution, ...

via breivik delusional disorder - Google Blog Search by Kristina Chew on 6/21/12
Read more: aspergers, bomb, breivik, delusional-disorder, far right, fundamentalism, islamophobia, mental illness, norway, oslo, paranoia, right wing, schizophrenia, terror, terrorism, Tourette, utoya. Photo with Utøya Island in ...


Wall Street Journal


Prosecutors Want Breivik in Hospital
Wall Street Journal
... killer to be considered insane and asked the court to sentence him to compulsory psychiatric care. ... Order a reprint of this article now; The Wall Street Journal ...

and more »



Prescutor: Breivik should be put in psychiatric care, not prison
DigitalJournal.com
Norwegian Prosecutor Svein Holden said a verdict needs to be reached to finally decide whether or not Anders Behring Breivik is clinically sane.


CTV.ca


Public still respects court psychiatry
Views and News from Norway
The survey, conducted by research firm Norstat for Norwegian Broadcasting ... those questioned retain the same level of confidence they had in court psychiatry.
Prosecutors ask for psychiatric care not prison for BreivikCTV.ca

all 1,278 news articles »

via international psychiatry journals - Google Blog Search by Views and News staff on 6/21/12
The traumatic trial of confessed Norwegian terrorist Anders Behring Breivik has raised major questions over the role of forensic psychiatry in Norway's legal system. Conflicting diagnoses of Breivik's mental health have resulted in serious doubt over whether he can be punished for his ... and News from Norway/Nina Berglund. Please support our news service. Readers in Norway can use our donor account. Our international readers can click on our “Donate” button: ...

No comments:

Post a Comment